Friday, April 23, 2010

"We Live in Public"/Cyberracism/Drunk Guy Looking for his Shoes

So we went over two things in class this week that I have been thinking a little more about. The first of these is the trailer we watched for We Live in Public, that documentary where the people are being recorded all the time in some underground world in New York. The whole idea of these people being "artists" is odd to me. I pretty quickly realized that for the most part they're not really the kind of artists that paint pictures. They're more like the ones that do live exhibits of themselves flossing for 36 hours in a glass room. I'm starting to think that "artist" is just another word for someone who is artsy and unemployed. Anyway, I wasn't able to find the movie online (for free) but I did read a few reviews that made me think that this Josh Harris guy may not be firing on all cylinders. I'm mainly talking about how he was kind of an odd kid and was obsessed with Gilligan's Island in an uncomfortable way. The guy blew 2 million dollars on a creepy social experiment/case study that included himself having a psychotic break. Weird, right? Maybe its just me. Doesn't this guy get that his experiment is not anything like real life? For one, all of the subjects are "artists", so its not a very good sampling of people. Also, everyone knows that people act differently in front of cameras so its not very telling of what people are like. Most importantly, though, these people are living in an underground world, not the real world where there are non-artist people. This is about as real as Flavor of Love.

The other topic we discussed this past week was cloaked websites and cyberracism from Jessie Daniels' article. I'll keep what I have to say about this one as to-the-point as possible. When the internet was first taking off, everyone was excited about the freedom of it and all of its potentials (internet fantasy). Now, once someone makes a website that is secretly backed by Neo-Nazis, something must be done! Newsflash: the internet, like real life, isn't perfect (global reality). Too bad people. In fact, I think one of the best rights we have as Americans is free speech, and in my mind if you're not for it, you're against it. We need to accept that racists unfortunately have the right to free speech too, even though most of us would rather not have to listen to it. Trying to restrict free speech online kind of reminds me of something China would do, and that scares me. Think about it, without free speech online we wouldn't have sites like PerezHilton or those political blogs people are into. Who wants a world like that? Maybe we just need to work on getting better at catching cloaked sites so kids don't accidentally get expelled over a paper they wrote on Martin Luther King Jr. Until then, here's some YouTube freedom of speech (and video) for you.


Here's a link to another video that is more related to free speech. I was just afraid of all of the bad language being an issue for some people so I made it a link instead of embedding it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zpkNUePQcZs&feature=channel

Saturday, April 17, 2010

Cyberbullying PSA's: About as Useless as Any Other PSA

This week we talked about cyberbullying and looked at a few Public Service Announcements (PSA's) about the issue. I did notice that a handfull of other blogs talked about this subject as well, so I'll try not to be repetitive.

The fact of the matter is, cyber bullying needs to be addressed. It is clearly huge problem with serious consequences, but the PSA's I've seen about it are generally rediculous and innefective. To be perfectly honest, I really don't think that any PSA's are a good use of airtime. All they seem to do is get fun of by kids and work parents up into a "moral panic" until little Jimmy is getting his laptop thrown away by his crazy mother. I guess he'll be doing homework on notebook paper now. My main problem with these ads is that they don't offer the kids with enough of a practical solution. Is a kid really going to tell his teachers that he is being bullied on MySpace and risk being called a tattle tale in addition to the bullying that was already happening? I doubt it.

I've done some thinking about two of the PSA's we watched in class. I'm doing this to point out why they are innefective (other than the fact that they are PSAs in the first place) and just basically say what I think about them. Quick disclaimer: these are just my opinions; I am no expert on cyberbullying or PSA's whatsoever. For all I know PSA's could be helping bullied kids, but probably not.

The first PSA (below) shows a young girl on a stage in front of her classmates. She is saying all of the awful thinks kids say in the privacy of their "glass bedrooms" to a girl in the audience. The message is that you wouldn't say the horrible things you (the bully) says online in person. This is again, not a valid comparison between online and offline lives and behaviors, but I'll ignore that. It made me think that if everyone went on stage and did the same thing it would be like that part in Mean Girls where everyone gets to see what was in the burn book. A massive school wide fight breaks out. This probably would never happen in real life, but neither would what the PSA suggests. My biggest problem with the ad is that it is trying to reach the bully. That won't work. The bully will make fun of the commercial and just make thinks worse on the kids being bullied. The other one we watched was better in this sense.



Another short video we saw in class (below) showed different teens switching on lightbulbs and saying little half sentences about who they are, what they like to do online, and how they will NOT be cyberbullied. To me, these people seemed a little bit older than the main bullying age group, but thats OK becaues this PSA was heading in the right direction. At least they weren't trying to go after the bullies or scare the parents, which would only have made things worse. These kids need to know that they can't just let the bullying happen, but they also need to know that they shouldn't go tattle to a teacher. I can't imagine how that wouldn't only make the bullying worse while the bully wouldn't really get punished. Again, this doesn't offer a viable solution. Maybe because there is no really good solution to cyber bullying, other than cyber bullying them back. I guess a lot of people would say thats a bad idea. Those bullied kids just need to remember that those bullies will probably grow up to be overweight security guards anyway.


Thursday, April 8, 2010

Cass Sunstein is Officially a Hater


I'm just going to put this out there: I've had about enough of the Cass Sunstein's of the world. Basically, I think that he is trying to scare people who don't know any better away from the upsides of the internet by telling them it will end person-to-person contact as we know it. He should be ashamed of himself. Not only do I not agree with some of his assertions in Sunstein's article, "The Daily We", I think his ideas about personalization and democracy are ludicrous (not the one pictured). I will focus on two areas where Sunstein shows that he may be in the early stages of dementia. These are his ideas that personalization is hurting our knowledge of shared experiences, and his overall treatment of the Thabo Mbeki situation.

Quick side note on Sunstien's approach in, "The Daily We". He really needs to stop comparing the internet to real life (i.e. the Public Forum Doctrine BS). Its like comparing apples and oranges, except apples and oranges are at least both fruits. Real life is nothing like the time you spend online. David Weinberger points to this in, "Echo Chambers=Democracy" by the way. The internet provides its users with time away from real life annoyances (like many of the people who exercise their Public Forum rights). The only way I can see making the internet considerably more like real life with regard to the Public Forum Doctrine is to add more pop-ups. Good one Cass, lets just add more stuff to sift through until you get to what you actually want to see.

OK, back to the shared experience thing. Sunstein thinks that our personalization online will make us lack shared experiences in real life. So he basically thinks that we will only be able to talk to people about the weather at some point. Newsflash Mr. Sunstien: we can't immediately relate to anyone we don't already know. When I'm on the elevator with someone and they feel the need to chat, the weather is the only uncontroversial thing that I am sure we can both relate to. That is, of course, unless they are a total shut in. But shut ins probably don't ride elevators often. Our regular internet free lives affect our experience much more than the sites we gravitate to. I watch the shows I like and read magazines I like. No one (I think) reads a broad range of magazines to better see other viewpoints. Therefore, my shared experiences are already limited.

The other part of the Sunstein article that really stood out to me is the way he chose to view the Thabo Mbeki situation. So Mbeki (ex president of South Africa), went online and became convinced that HIV does not lead to AIDS by a group called "the denialists". Aside from this story officially making Mbeki one of the most irresponsible presidents I have ever heard of, Sunstein thinks the former president was a VICTIM of a cybercascade. Sunstein, there is no excuse for this level of stupidity from the leader of a country no matter how much you think the internet is destroying the world. The real victims are the South Africans who were HIV positive and now have AIDS and didn't get treated because their trusted president told them not to. Just because untrue theories are all over the internet doesn't mean we should believe them without any evidence.

Furthermore, just because Cass Sunstein keeps running his mouth doesn't mean those who know better have to listen.

Picture from: http://www.desktopexchange.com/gallery/albums/Music-Wallpapers/ludacris_pictures_2.jpg

Friday, March 26, 2010

MUD Crime? Really?


My feelings on the selections from Wu and Goldsmith's, “Who Controls the Internet: Illusions of a Borderless World” are predicated on an opinion that I feel I need to make abundantly clear. That point is that it is my opinion that people with an obsessive interest in MUDs (Multi User Dungeons) do not lead normal, healthy, socially acceptable lives. Even the name MUD reflects an uncomfortable level of internet obsession. Think about it: Multi (normal) User (normal) Dungeon (not normal). Yes, dungeon as in the place where criminals with the plague went in medieval Europe—or something. History is not my strong suit.

If we expect these online worlds to be fun and, according to Wu and Goldsmith, liberating, these online spaces really shouldn't be called dungeons. Dungeons are known for trapping people, not liberating them. Why aren't they called something tamer like Multi User Playgrounds? Or maybe a more realistic option like Multi User Communities? With the connotation of the word dungeon, it is no wonder that LambdaMOO has mean users like Mr. Bungles picking on poor innocent ones like Legba and Starsinger.

In, “Who Controls the Internet”, there is a discussion about how the deplorable online actions of Mr. Bungle were terrorizing the upstanding citizens of LambdaMOO. Mr. Bungle's actions apparently made the citizens realize that a set of rules must be put in place. I actually started to get used to this idea and side with the concerned citizens. I figured that the people of LambdaMOO would set up something like a neighborhood watch and that Mr. Bungle would end up as a gang member in the the LambdaMOO county jail. While this was happening, poor Legba and Starsinger would be put in cyber therapy and would refuse to leave their houses without packing heat. Time out. This is all a FAKE world.

For a second there I was almost as crazy as the actual MUD users. This online “world” is not real. Mr. Bungle could be a twelve year old kid for all we know (with a name that sounds more like one of my grandmother's cats). No matter how old he is, he never actually physically touched those online tattle tales Legba and Starsinger. So whats the big deal? If your life is being so negatively effected by MUDs, you probably don't have all of your ducks in line and you also probably don't have too many tangible friends. What these prisoners of the Multi User Dungeons need to do is slowly step away from their computer and try to enjoy the real outdoors for once. I repeat: if your life online is so bad, why don't you give an online life a try?

Maybe quitting LambdaMOO is easier said than done. Its like an abusive relationship to the Starsingers and Legbas of the (online) world. If this is the case, it sounds to me like it is time for some internet rehab for those two. While the abused people go to internet rehab, Mr. Bungle should head over to Korea for some LambdaMOO court ordered “Netiquette”. Ugh, give me a break.


Thursday, March 18, 2010

An Internet Intervention... on the Tyra Banks Show


Normally, I would write about this week's readings or at least something we have been talking about. Not today. The reason that this post will have nothing to do with Shirky or Scholz is that I saw something on TV last week that I absolutely have to write about. It was pure Tyra Banks low budget talk show gold.

On my spring break I didn't spend my time napping on a beach, instead I caught up on some daytime television that usually conflicts with my class schedule. And where do you find such quality programming? The CW of course. On the Tyra Banks show, no topic is too dumb and no hairpiece is too unrealistic. The episode that I am talking about in this instance is about an internet addict. Tyra was determined to get to the bottom of this growing problem. The girl that came on the show had recently lost her job, failed to register for college classes, and become a total outcast from her family as a result of her addiction to social networking and technology as a whole. In some ways the episode was like A&E's Intervention. It had pretty much the same formula, including the supportive friend who sets them up for an intervention when they actually think their addiction was just being profiled for some reason on TV. The only differences were that it was in front of a live audience, Tyra Banks was the interventionist, and of course that it is not really a legitimate addiction.
After the awkward "intervention" portion of the show, the addict was sent to roam New York City for a day in attempts to make real friends. This was not much of a success. Then, the girl was subject to a hidden camera test where she was put in a room alone with a computer. Sadly, she relapsed in a moment of weakness and checked her Facebook. Not to worry, Tyra caught up with the recovering addict a week later and she proudly announced that she was doing much better and had been using the internet only in moderation. The episode was even more ridiculous than it sounds.

Ok, the point of this post is not just to vent my feelings on an episode of Tyra. Watching this episode had me thinking about Digital Nation and the internet rehab in Korea. When I first saw that portion of the documentary, I thought that this could never happen in America. Now I see it a little bit differently. Maybe the way that those Korean kids feel about gaming is similar to the way some Americans are acting toward their Social Networking Sites. Admittedly, Facebook is not killing us like the Korean arcades do--but apparently it is starting to effect some peoples' futures. Pretty soon the United States will have to consider something like Korea's "Netiquette" lessons. Lets hope that's a stretch.

Friday, February 26, 2010

Digital Nation: My Thoughts

Originally I was going to write this week's blog on free software and the readings for the week, but I still can't stop thinking about the video we watched in class. Digital Nation: Life on the Virtual Frontier is a PBS documentary directed and produced by Rachel Dretzin with correspondent Douglas Rushkoff; where several areas of life in a digital world are examined. Two parts of what we watched in class were particularly thought provoking for me.

First, the portion about the young computer game addicted Korean boy who is shipped off to "Digital Detox" when his mother decides that his internet addition has gotten out of control. (Video Below).

There is mention that the Korean government now considers internet addition to be a mental disorder. I see it more as bad behavior. The young boy in the video (as well as countless others) are spending days on end playing video games to the point that they injure themselves-- all under the noses of their helpless parents. Why aren't these children's parents taking away some of their computer privileges or not allowing them to go to the "PC Bangs" for days at a time?The mother talks about how she felt she had lost touch with her son and how she wishes she could play the video games with him. Seriously? Then she could eventually be sent to internet detox herself and child services would probably get involved. Maybe a bad idea.

The second area that I keep thinking about is the part where the inner city public school in the Bronx had been changed for the better because all of the students were given laptops. (Video Below).


This was a refreshingly positive view on the digital revolution. The students' test scores and behavior improved and everyone seemed pretty happy there. Everything looked like it was the way technology should be. That was until they showed the assistant principal remotely monitoring the students computers for "inappropriate use". In my mind, what the assistant principal was doing was much more inappropriate than the students finding a way onto MySpace and Youtube. This man was watching the girls adjust their makeup and do their hair through his computer. It just seems odd to me. The students know that they are able to be monitored but it still feels like a bit of an invasion of privacy since the students are essentially being spied on via webcam. Fortunately, it looks like this type of monitoring won't last too much longer. Stories like the lawsuit on behalf of a high school student who was monitored by the school while he was at home are all over the internet now. It seems like sometimes the adults, not the children, are using the internet irresponsibly.


Friday, February 19, 2010

Thompson vs. Dvorak: a Tasteless Catfight


As I switch back and forth from looking over the readings from this past week on One Laptop Per Child and watching the Olympics: two things come to mind. First, I can't believe how much the Curling stones like Snorks (see picture). The second, and more important thing that comes to mind is how ridiculous the bickering between each side of the OLPC debate is. The first article we were assigned is a very harsh criticism of Nicholas Negroponte's OLPC by John Dvorak called, "One Laptop per Child Doesn't Change the World". The second article was a particularly catty response to Dvorak's article entitled, "Give me Rice, but Give me a Laptop Too" by Bill Thompson. Both of these writers have clearly forgotten about the impoverished children, and are more concerned with verbally bashing the opposing viewpoint.

Basically, I feel like Dvorak and Thompson's issues began before the writing of these articles (judging by the way Thompson talked about Dvorak). Maybe Dvorak tagged an unflattering picture of Thompson on Facebook or something. Whatever the case may be, these two "journalists" are acting more childish than the potential recipients of the XO Laptops.

First, big bad bully John Dvorak writes, "Think of how cool it would be! Think of how many families will get the experience the friendly spam-ridden Information Super Ad-Way laced with Nigerian scams, hoaxes, porn, blogs, wikis spam, urban folklore, misinformation, sites selling junk from China, etc,". For the most part, I actually agree with Dvorak in that I think that OLPC is a bad idea. That being said, he should know better than to use such a harsh tone when talking about an attempt to fix a social problem; especially when it is going to be published for the world to see.

Image from: http://totallylookslike.files.wordpress.com/2009/09/marble-curling-thing-totally-looks-like-a-snork.jpg
Then the nerdy BBC writer, Bill Thompson read Dvorak's article on his Kindle. The first thing he did was tell his cats about how mean John Dvorak is, and then he wrote an article in response, "Give me Rice, but Give me a Laptop Too". Thompson writes, "Perhaps he [Dvorak] is just afraid that a Nigerian schoolchild, empowered by the technology entrusted to them, will take him to task for his patronizing attitude, or perhaps even turn out to be a better journalist. It wouldn't be hard". Oh snap! Real classy Bill Thompson, a dig on Dvorak's writing abilities. Each of you two crazy kids need a timeout and at least one detention. Actually, a timeout should give them plenty of time to think about all of the poor, starving, laptop-less children that are being affected.

Friday, February 12, 2010

Why Tapscott is Giving us Too Much Credit

Since the region was inundated with snow for the past week or so many people, like myself, didn't know exactly what to do with all of our school-less free time (not a complaint by any means). I began by doing what I normally do: brushing up on as much celebrity news as I can handle. Unfortunately it was a very slow entertainment news week. Seriously, TMZ needs to understand that no one cares about Charlie Sheen's marriage. Other than that I, like many other people, brushed up on my meteorology in order to determine how much school exactly we stood to miss. I basically could put Al Roker out of a job with my knowledge of dew points and barometric pressure at this point. After I had done enough weather predicting for about a year I started to think about how even though I was feeling trapped by the snow and finished with my box set of Law and Order: SVU, I still was thrilled to be not in school. With this in mind, I took a second look at Don Tapscott's, "The Impending Demise of the University".

As I looked over the article, I found several places where I think that Tapscott showed how far removed he is from actually being a student at a University. Personally, I'm not sure where he got the idea that he was an expert on how present day college students feel about school. I don't claim to know what a sixty five year old man's motives are, so why does he think he knows my (or other students') feelings about our classes. He did, of course, have some very valid points about how to make classes more interesting for students in the digital age, but there are some other points he made that I felt were a little bit off. Here are some examples.

p. 2: "Students, who have grown up in an interactive digital world, learn differently. Schooled on Google and Wikipedia, they want to inquire, not rely on the professor for a detailed roadmap. They want an animated conversation, not a lecture."

This to me sounds like an excuse that Don Tapscott's son made for a poor attendance policy. While animated conversations would undoubtedly be much more interesting and ideal for classes within your field of study, requirements (i.e. Philosophy) on the other hand, I only take to pass. I think I speak for most CUA students when I say that we just want to get some of our required classes out of the way. In non-major required classes, If a very interactive teacher gives a ton of work and grades really hard, while another gives boring lectures and has easy tests I think most of us would take the latter. Tapscott seems to be forgetting that students want to get good grades, not just learn as much as possible.

p. 3: "They're used to multi-tasking, and have learned to handle the information overload."

Tapscott doesn't seem to understand that just because some people feel the need to be on Facebook all day every day, does not mean that they are expert multi-taskers. While it is possible to do homework and juggle friend requests at the same time, it doesn't mean that the quality of the work is good or that it is done as fast as it would have been otherwise. Tapscott is giving University students way too much credit.

p. 7: "These universities are vulnerable, especially at a time when students can watch lectures online for free by some of the world's leading professors on sites like Academic Earth...nearly 20 per cent of college students — some 3.9 million people — took an online course in 2007, and their numbers are growing by hundreds of thousands each year."

Mr. Tapscott, the students are not using these sites to see lectures from the best professors in different fields, they are doing online classes because they fit into almost any schedule and often they're seen as easier since there are no monitored tests. Many people do learn a lot from online lectures, but the main reason people take online classes is because of convenience.

The bottom line here is that in the University experience, you get out what you put in. If a student is interested in a class, they will learn and pay attention. Unfortunately for Don Tapscott, I do not believe it has much to do with being an expert multi-tasker.

Images from: http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.memeticians.com/2008/12/18/SnowDay.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.memeticians.com/2008/12/&usg=__DibV9SNBaAjMJZfhYtwRioJeI6I=&h=600&w=800&sz=68&hl=en&start=3&um=1&itbs=1&tbnid=ObMopgLIge-TMM:&tbnh=107&tbnw=143&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dsnow%2Bday%26hl%3Den%26safe%3Doff%26sa%3DG%26um%3D1 and http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://symonsez.files.wordpress.com/2008/07/boring20lecture-thumb.jpg&imgrefurl=http://symonsez.wordpress.com/2008/07/17/jose-roger-or-bill-who-is-the-best-fighter/&usg=__BmIPsXb4jlYUueCGNAJQG76WnCc=&h=167&w=250&sz=7&hl=en&start=6&um=1&itbs=1&tbnid=pdJSJ_Su6kfoHM:&tbnh=74&tbnw=111&prev=/images%3Fq%3Dboring%2Blecture%26hl%3Den%26safe%3Doff%26sa%3DG%26um%3D1

Friday, February 5, 2010

The Digital Divide: Do we really need to do something about it?


For the past week or so our class time has been focused on the "digital divide". This refers to the discrepancy between the numbers of people who have online connectivity and those who do not. The term is usually used in relation to the divide on a global scale in reference to economic status, but it can also refer to divides areas such as race, gender, and age. In one of the presentations on Thursday the age divide (and what is being done about it) was highlighted. The presenter showed us OldNet. Honestly, it took me a pretty long time to get past that it was called OldNet. Do the old people that are trying to benefit from their services know the name of the organization? It should be "Seasoned Net" or at the very least "Elderly Net". Anyway, it really got me thinking about why we even need to be trying to fix the digital divide. Do the people that are supposed to be benefiting from organizations like OldNet and OLPC (One Laptop per Child) even want this kind of help? I know that if I told my grandmother that someone was willing to teach her how to use the internet for free she would tell me she'd rather read a book or knit. If someone really wanted to help her with something she actually needs they can help with her perscription costs. I think that the same is true for OLPC, especially as it relates to one of their most recent endeavors.

Since the devastating earthquake in Haiti, OLPC has begun a campaign to send used XO laptops to Haiti. The organization's entire platform focuses on reducing the digital divide in developing countries by giving every child a laptop. The idea is ridiculous in my opinion, especially in Haiti's case. Last time I checked you can't eat a laptop. A laptop also can't put a roof over your head or give you the healthcare you and your family desperately need. Seriously, what good would this do? So what if all of the Haitian children can look at Wyclef's Jean's twitter five times a day if they are still starving? OLPC needs to understand that you need to crawl before you walk. Developing countries all over the world need to build themselves up economically until they can even consider Skyping their pen pal in America. At least thats what I think.

Images from (http://www.oldpeopletalkingabouttheinternet.com/ and http://rbg-street-scholar-multi-media-e-zine.blogspot.com/2007_03_01_archive.html)

Friday, January 29, 2010

The Art of the Facebook Performance



For my first blog this semester I will be shedding some light on the way Facebook can be used to analyze online performances. By online performances I'm not talking about this type of performance, but rather what Erika Pearson was talking about in her article, "All the World Wide Web's a Stage: The Performance of Identity in Online Social Networks. She uses "online performance" to explain how people portray themselves in their online personas, and how it may differ from their real life personalities. In Pearson's article she calls the way that people try to portray themselves (online or offline) their front-stage lives. Inversely, the way people actually act is their back-stage life. As a light to moderate Facebook user, I have seen first hand how these performances play out online.
Aside from the profile pictures choose (that myself and Stephanie have both analyzed), there are other ways to see identity performance online. Every time you go Facebook stalking you see a number of examples of how people try so desperately to keep up a certain online appearance. One example is when you see people untag a picture of themselves when they look a little rough.

(OK that picture of Lindsay Lohan is not from Facebook or anything, but its plenty rough)

Another example is when people want to look smart so they put an exhaustive list of long books (Crime and Punishment, Moby Dick, the Dictionary, etc.) in their info section. Also, if people want to look like party animals their interests would read like this: partying, drinking, skipping class, drinking, crushing beer cans on my head, drinking... you get the point. Erika Pearson would (accurately) describe these types of people as "performing".

An interesting point to bring up about performing and the interaction between front-stage and back-stage personas is how seriously we should be taking the personalities people try to portray online. What is more of a performance: The way people you don't know very well (weak ties) act in person, or the way they appear in their online profiles? One experience I have had makes it very difficult to tell.

Off and on for the past few years I have been working for a very inauthentic Italian restaurant with some questionable co-workers. One of the people I used to work with was especially creepy and awkward. To protect his identity I'll call him Creep. One of my friends and I were curious about his age so I friended him on Facebook to try and figure it out (he could have been anywhere from 20-50). When I looked at his pictures as a window into Creep's "real" life, he seemed a lot more normal than he usually acts. He had pictures out at bars with friends (who seemed about 35), a few with his family on vacation, and even some with his cats. Other than his cat ownership, he seemed relatively normal online. So this begs the question: who is the real Creep? Is he the one that brings a thermos to work every day and is always behind you listening in on your conversations, or is he the guy in the pictures hanging out with friends? Which identity is the one being performed? This just goes to show how easy it is to be fooled by the way people express their front-stage and back-stage selves.

Photos from: http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v313/nollpost/mrnspace/funny-pictures-facebook-library-cat.jpg, http://malditovivant.files.wordpress.com/2009/03/lindsay-lohan-drunk-400a071907.jpg

Thursday, December 10, 2009

Party Crashing with the Salahi's


For my last blog of the semester I couldn't think of anything good, so I again turned to very important news story. This time I kept the story a bit closer to home. By home I mean DC and by important story I of course, mean the White House Party Crashers: Tareq and Michaele Salahi. Now this is a particularly interesting situation because this is both a tabloid story as well as a mainstream news story. It lends itself to my kind of news since the couple is linked to Bravo's "Real Housewives of DC" series. Way to stay classy DC. It is also, of course, a mainstream news story as well since it took place at the White House. Since it was both mainstream and trashy news at the same time, it was covered by both types of news sources (CNN.com and TMZ). The two online sources cover the same story from different angles, thus explaining why I prefer TMZ.

Now, before I go into that, I feel the need to first mention how I feel about this story. I give the Salahi's a lot of credit for crashing this party. Personally, I would probably not even want to go in the first place, since I highly doubt that there was a Karaoke machine or any awkward keg stand falls to witness. Nonetheless, if someone is willing to crash this nap of a party I think they should be rewarded. As far as I am concerned a White House party is nothing more a rager at the Obamas. With that in mind, I feel like people shouldn't really be turned away from similar house parties as long as they pay the hosts. I'm sure Tareq and Michaele would have been comfortable with paying some secret service guy $5 at the door for a red solo cup and getting some X's drawn on their hands. If White House parties were like normal house parties, the money they would make could probably fix the recession.

Instead of going over every word of the two articles, you can get an idea of what makes them so different from the headlines. CNN.com's recent article about these party crashers was entitled: White House Crashers Named in 16 Civil Suits. TMZ's article was called: How Do You Get to the White House? Practice. Basically, TMZ is a little bit more low brow, not to mention more at my reading level. I'm not even really sure what a Civil Suit actually is. Honestly, without TMZ I probably would never have heard of the story. It just goes to show how different online media sources reach different audiences. It also suggests why these different outlets reach their targeted demographics: the reading level they are written at.

Thursday, December 3, 2009

Tough Week for Tiger


Some people watch CNN and read the Wall Street Journal. Not me. My idea of news is more likely found on E! News and Us Weekly. Earlier this week I had planned on writing something about the political media issues we had been talking about in class. Luckily, some of the news I had been hearing this week allowed me to stay well within my area of expertise. The tabloid gods smiled on my world this week and provided me with the breaking news that grade-A cornball Tiger Woods had crashed his Escalade (so much for those Buick Ads) into a fire hydrant when being chased out of his house by his infuriated wife. Her tirade was sparked by finding out that Tiger had been having an affair with THREE women, one of which was seen on the first season of Tool Academy (seriously Tiger?). To make this news even better, his wife smashed out his window with...wait for it... a golf club. So I guess I was right in thinking that Tiger Woods' house was decorated with 50% portraits of him and 50% golf clubs. The man loves his sport, and apparently not so much his wife.

The news was broken by a source that seems to be the first at every celebrity related story: TMZ. The website not only the biggest and most thorough celebrity related website, but also the reason that this was even such a huge story. If it wasn't for TMZ and other entertainment blog sites the story probably would have just been that Tiger Woods had crashed his car into a fire hydrant. The more provocative angles that blogs are not afraid to take, as seen in the case of Trent Lott's comments at the Strom Thurmond Birthday party, make it possible for more salacious news stories to spread like wildfire. This aspect of blogs is the reason that Tiger Woods is in "intensive marriage counseling" and is being forced to have his prenuptial agreement renegotiated. This is actually working out decently business-wise for his wife since she could not possibly have any more leverage against him. The new agreement will probably be as follows: If Tiger cheats on her again, she gets her own island. The angles that these blogs take also made it possible for these stories to grow so quickly, since they don't have to wait until the following day to post their news like newspapers do. Not ten minutes after the story that the cheesiest athlete in the lamest sport ever has a mistress from VH1's Tool Academy, the world got a truly awesome soundbite from a voicemail that he left her:



He has a very distinctly goofy voice, so he really didn't have to say that "this is Tiger". Sounding like that, its a good thing he is a filthy rich professional athlete. Nonetheless, these types of stories would never blow up in the media like this if it wasn't for blogs. They really are the quickest and most brutally honest (or sometimes brutally unreliable) news source. That being said, I don't feel bad at all about getting most of my news from blogs. Who needs CNN when you can get news like this on TMZ?

Just for fun: below is a photo of Tiger's girlfriend number three and her Ex from Tool Academy (just in case anyone is crazy enough to miss an episode or two).


Thursday, November 19, 2009

Where do you get your (Kardashian) News?


This week we talked in class about how we got our News; either on the Internet or on Television. Evidence in the rise of Internet use for campaign news is seen through the PEW Research Center's, "Internet's Broader Role in Campaign 2008". Television is still number one (although it has dropped two percent points), but the Internet as a Campaign News source has nearly doubled from 13% to 24% between 2004 and 2008. Although this study is only in relation to Campaign News, I think that the same trends are true for any type of News. The reasons that I see for this are 1. more and more people are using the Internet at a very young age and 2. that the Internet is where most news stories are broken today.

In the past 5 years or so, the Internet really has become the fastest way to get News. In fact, I think that the reason that television is still number one is because old people who like to watch the news and are interested in the subject matter that PEW did their research on, are not the demographic of people who regularly use the Internet. Admittedly, I'm not a big fan of Television news or even most of the subject matter on news shows. I am, however, an avid fan of E! News and Perezhilton.com. Britney Spears falling out of a Limo, scraping her knee, and being rushed to Cedars-Sinai for a mental evaluation is more important than healthcare, right?

A somewhat recent event illustrated both the fact that the Internet gets News out much faster than Television and the generation gap between people who use online and offline News sources. About one month ago the epic News broke that Khloe Kardashian and professional basketball player (and amateur ogre) Lamar Odom were getting married. This News story was on Perezhilton.com several hours before Ryan Seacrest was able to report it on E! News. The gap between when the engagement was reported online and when it was seen on E! News means that if I had waited to see the report on Television, I would have gone much of my day without knowing that two of the most influential people on Television were joining forces. That would have been awful. All joking aside, Internet users knew the news story several hours before it aired on E! News. Like most other current news stories, the Internet was where the story originally broke.

The Kardashian-Odom nuptial News also exposed the generation gap between people who get News from the Internet and those who get their News from Television. This happened when on the E! "Keeping Up with the Kardashians: The Wedding" reality show, it was revealed that Bruce Jenner (and whats left of his face), didn't know about his step-daughter's engagement until he saw it on the News. Because he doesn't use the Internet for News, Bruce didn't know his daughter was getting married until days after the couple was engaged and the story was originally broken. Don't get me wrong, I am well aware that this show is scripted, rehearsed, and edited within an inch of its life (no one wakes up every morning with fake eyelashes and styled hair). Nonetheless, even the suggestion that a father would not know that his daughter was getting married until days after the engagement because he waited for the TV News is very telling. If Bruce had been using the Internet for his News, he would have probably known about the wedding plans before the couple told anyone else in the family. In fact, I probably knew about the engagement before most of the Kardashians did.

Image from: http://assets.nydailynews.com/img/2009/10/01/alg_khloe-kardashian_lamar-odom.jpg


Thursday, November 12, 2009

Dear Adults: Get out of my Face(book)


The article, "Are Baby Boomers Killing Facebook and Twitter?", by Robert Strohmeyer suggests that there is a chance that adults around the age of 50 could eventually drive young people away from Facebook and Twitter. Hell to the no. In his defense he doesn't say that this will definitely happen on a large scale, but the mere suggestion makes it clear that he is completely out of touch with youths on Facebook. Facebook is more important than breathing to a lot of people I come in contact with. In fact, if you look at at least 75% of the laptops on campus you will find Facebook on the bookmarks toolbar (often between Cardinalmail and Perezhilton). Nobody parts with anything on their bookmarks toolbar.

It would be more accurate to say that the rise of Facebooking old people (I mean the term lovingly, I'm down with old people) has changed the way the younger generation uses privacy settings on Facebook. Threats of online pedophiles and stalkers couldn't even do that. The fear of an adult seeing your party pictures is scarier than pedophiles to most young adults. Take that Chris Hansen. In fact, I never worried about my privacy settings until my older relatives started friending me on Facebook. This wasn't really about my pictures, though, it was more about the awkward wall posts I was getting. That is no longer allowed because of one particular incident.

Last semester, right when adults were beginning to enter the world of Facebook, I got a wall post from a balding, mustachioed 45 year old man that read: "Hey sweetie! I haven't seen you in so long, what are you doing for Spring break?". Awesome. This inevitably led to numerous Facebook messages asking me who that creepy man on my wall was and why he was calling me 'sweetie'. Relax, I'm not that down with old people. The man that wrote on my wall is my uncle who does not share my last name. He is very nice and not creepy at all but I couldn't let him continue to write things like that on my wall. I changed my privacy settings so that he could no longer see my entire profile. Luckily I never had to tell him why. It would have been incredibly awkward to tell him he can't write 'sweetie' on my wall because it makes him look like a pedophile. Even the suggestion is stomach turning.

The point of this is to show that adults could never chase young people away from their precious Facebook as Robert Strohmeyer's, "Are Baby Boomers Killing Facebook and Twitter" suggests. What adults on Facebook can do, though, is change the way we use it. These adults have done much more for Privacy settings than fear over stalkers and pedophiles could ever do. Old(er) people on Facebook: 1, Dateline: To Catch a Predator: 0.

Picture from: http://sheconomy.files.wordpress.com/2009/04/elderly-people-on-computer.jpg

Thursday, November 5, 2009

Multiple Teen MySpace Pages Revealed... On "The Tyra Show"


This week in class we spoke about people who use multiple pages on Social Networking Sites for different types of people to see. Some adults, for example, use one for personal use and one for professional use. What is more interesting to me was when teens do this to hide what they are doing online from protective parents. As we were talking about this I was thinking that there is no way people actually did this and their parents didn't know about it. One of televisions greatest programs proved me wrong.

Almost every day my roommates and myself crowd around the television at 3pm after seeing the paternity test results from the end of Maury to watch the most ridiculous show on television: The Tyra Show. Although Tyra (we call her Tyrone) thinks that she is the next Oprah, it would be a stretch to call her the next Maury. We keep watching nonetheless. On one episode last week the topic was "Teen Promiscuity", which I'm sure had Maury feeling ripped off. A 15 year old girl on the show decided to come clean (on national television) to her mother about her behavior because she found out that she was pregnant. Tyra was basically there for moral support and to provide the free meal that comes with appearing on a CW show (the girl is eating for two). This promiscuous teen had been telling her mother that when she was getting dropped off after school at a roller rink she was actually leaving and going to see much older boys that she met online. First, why is this mother dumb enough to think that her daughter would want to go to a roller rink several times a week? Mom is clearly stuck in 1975.

The more pertinent part of this episode is that the young girl revealed to her mother that she had a second MySpace page under a different name that her mother was not ever supposed to see. Tyra revealed some of the PG-13 pictures to the audience (which were appalling), but others were to racy to show on TV and were revealed only to the hysterically crying mother. Apparently, the girl had been purposely leaving her fake MySpace page with the mom-safe pictures up in order to make her clueless mother think that her interests were "reading" and "church".

This had me thinking about how teens like the one on The Tyra Show were using MySpace as a way of rebelling. Instead of sneaking off when being taken to go rollerskating; she is instead sneaking off to her R-rated MySpace page when her parents weren't looking. This allowed her to create a new online identity (like Sherry Turkle talked about in "Who Am We?") for herself where she could act however she wanted without consequences. Unfortunately her online rebellion seemed to have spilled over to her real life, giving her about 18 years of consequences. The Emmy must be stuck in the mail, Tyra.

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

An Examination of the Facebook Profile Picture

While browsing Facebook today I noticed that there are several different distinct types of profile pictures according to the way people want to be represented. I may have missed a few but this is what I found:

The "I have friends" picture: This can also include family members in some cases. It is usually shot with the subject in the middle with one friend on either side. Everyone is smiling like they knew it would end up as someones Facebook picture. They were correct.

The "glamour shot": Usually these are alone and very posed. There are some tweaks on things like lighting that make it obvious that it was shot with an expensive camera.

The "angles": This shot was popularized by MySpace but it is a staple for adolescent teens. It is always taken by the subject and is usually either shot in the mirror (with the camera visible) or shot showing the subjects arm in the picture.

The "webcam" shot: These are most often used by people with white Macbooks. They are usually not smiling and often use some type of effect on the picture. This is the type of person that changes their profile picture every day.

The "face in the crowd": This is a picture that has too many people in it to discern who's profile it is without already knowing what they look like. This person could be either trying to remain anonymous or just doesn't have very many pictures to choose from. A common example of this is a picture of a sports team that the subject is a member of.

The "party animal": Party animals want the world to know that they like to rage. There is always some type of party face involved as if it is an action shot. Don't be fooled, it was posed.

The "black and white": This person just got a new camera. They also may think that they look better without coloring. I don't entirely understand this one. I think that there must be another reason behind it.

The "childhood picture": This person was probably a cute kid. These usually don't remain as profile pictures for long, but while they are up this person gets a lot compliments in the form of wall posts.

I probably left some out, but that is what myself and my friends have decided on for now.

Thursday, October 22, 2009

Moral Panic: Overblown?


When reading Wade Roush's article, "The Moral Panic over Social Networking Sites", I was shocked to know something about the controversy over online pedophiles: there really aren't that many of them. This, to me, was completely shocking. For most of my teen years my parents were constantly nagging me about how pedophiles can see my Facebook and that these types of people are all over the Internet. The issue of online pedophiles is a full blown moral panic. One of the features of a true moral panic is that the response to the threat is disproportionate to the actual threat. This can be seen not only in parents, but also in other forms of media. One example of this is what Television News, and more specifically "Dateline NBC: To Catch a Predator". This show basically took a small moral concern and turned it into a full fledged moral panic.

Just from watching the way that the pedophiles on the show are tricked into an extremely embarrassing and life ruining situation leads you to believe that the crime they have (not yet) committed is a HUGE problem. It only fuels parents' beliefs that their children are going to be targeted if Christ Hansen and NBC don't get to them first. The parents are then overprotective of their children online and things like the Deleting Online Predators Act are encouraged without enough careful consideration. Parents, as well as anyone else, need to examine the facts before diving into a moral panic. This is true especially when it comes to the Internet; a topic that many parents do not know very much about.
___________________________________________________

Not that it is completely related to the moral panic issue, but I have a few problems with the show. First, why are these people who may have just been a little (or a lot) creepy tricked into thinking that there are actual teenagers who are interested in them online? Any real young girl that actually wants to meet a 45 year old man online hasn't been raised well enough to use a computer. Secondly, why does Chris Hansen ask them what they were doing at the house when he has already seen their chats? Is he just trying to embarrass them? He's mean. Finally, why are the predators tackled by a mob of rabid police officers as if they had just found Osama Bin Laden? These men are usually overweight and over the hill. Not exactly the type to fight back.

Picture from: http://img245.imageshack.us/i/predator.jpg/

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

I Guess Nothing is Private Anymore


For very good reason, privacy seems to be the main concern about social network sites. People who do not use these sites have always said that you never know who could be out there looking at your pictures and (according to my parents) stalking you. This is the reason that I really hope that my parents never see Kevin Poulsen's article, "MySpace Bug Leaks 'Private' Teen Photos to Voyeurs". I don't know if I could handle warnings about how the "pedo army" is out to get me every time I see them. I'm too old for those creeps anyway. Apparently, "A backdoor in MySpace's architecture allows anyone who's interested to see the photographs of some users with private profiles". The article brings up an interesting concern about how MySpace profiles can be seen by the worst of people even when the MySpace users think that they have made their profiles private. With so many teenagers on MySpace who have private profiles being exploited, there are probably many more that do not have private profiles and never listened to the whispers about creepy people who could be looking at their pictures.

The phenomenon of misleading privacy settings is not only seen in the example of the MySpace bug. As seen in the most recent post on Laura's Stuff, you can view someone's Facebook profile picture and the network they are in when their name is typed into Google. I personally never intended on being Googleable. This is particularly worrisome because I had thought that my Facebook profile was private enough so that I could not be found by anyone who is not my Facebook friend or in my network. I was clearly wrong since I see that the entire world can now find me on Google. I guess Emily Nussbaum was right in thinking that "privacy doesn't exist anymore". It really makes you wonder why we trust what Facebook or MySpace claim to be their privacy settings so blindly when we've known all along that people like the "pedo army" are out there. Now all I can do is hope that my parents never get bored enough to Google my name.

Picture From: http://www.writers-free-reference.com/old-man-at-computer.jpg

Wednesday, October 7, 2009

Parents are Jealous of their Kids?


In Emily Nussbaum's article, "Say Everything" the SNS lives of several young people are followed. It examines not only their online use, but also how it relates to the ever shrinking generation gap between adults and the generation under about 25 that uses technology. This technology is considered foreign to many people over 40, including my parents. In the article it says that the current generation gap has not been seen since, "the early days of rock and roll". There is a claim that the older generation dislikes their children's new found Internet use partly because of jealousy for what adults did not have at their disposal. I feel that it is more jealousy that young people can easily navigate the technology than jealousy that young people are using SNS sites that their parents didn't have.

My own mother is a good example of this. She is constantly aggravated with my 15 year old brother's Facebook use because she believes that he should be spending his time on his computer doing homework. She says things like, "what is he doing?" "Who is he talking to?" "You know it could be any old creepy man on the other end!" Sure. I let my mother see my profile in order to appease her and prove to her that not everyone on Facebook is doing something that they would not want their parents seeing (even though I still think my brother is hiding something).

She needed much more direction than I had expected. I basically had to click every link for her while she looked through my sisters pictures and printed off the ones she liked. After she had at least twenty 8.5/11 inch print out pictures she was finished. I asked her how she liked it and her response was, "still stupid". Personally, I think that her response was a direct result of her frustration with the technology. She does not like it because, as the article says, "it doesn't come naturally" to her. That's just like how I would feel if someone wanted me to go hang out at a diner. I'd really rather not.

Picture (not my Mom) from: http://static.thefrisky.com/images/uploads/mom_computer_m.jpg

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

Privacy Settings Don't Always Work

There has been some talk around the blogs about privacy on social networking sites and who could possibly be seeing your page. It was in relation to the article, "Social Networking Sites: Definition, History, and Scholarship". Part of the article alluded to privacy of content and the possibility of people like, "police officers having the right to access content posted to Facebook without a warrant." This also relates more broadly to school authority figures and possible employers. The idea that this practice could ever be considered acceptable from companies and school systems bothers me. How is it not spying?

First, I will address the issue with schools using my high school as an example. I went to a small all girls' high school where nearly everyone had a Facebook page. I had heard whispers around the school that the administration would be able to look at your Facebook page and you could be punished for pictures you have posted. I never really believed any of it because neither I nor anyone I knew was Facebook friends with any of our teachers. Apparently you don't have to be because before long the Dean was calling students to her office with printed pictures of students holding red cups or having writing all over their faces (as long as they fell asleep with their shoes on). I don't know of any actual punishments that came out of this because people most likely made excuses like, "I needed a sharpie unibrow for a school project". My issue is that I don't even think that the students should have had to make excuses for behaviors that happen outside of school. I suppose that the school would say that they were just looking out for the students, but it certainly never felt that way. I still don't understand how the school was able to look at these people's Facebook pages. Maybe there was a student mole that friended people in exchange for good grades. Maybe not.

I also have some issues with employers looking at the Facebook profiles of people who are applying for jobs with their companies. What do they want to find? Pictures of people reading books and maybe a few with the family pet? What do they have against an employee who has fun? If I was hiring someone, I wouldn't want a fun sponge. That's just my opinion. Either way, why are they able to look at applicants' pages without them knowing? I feel like somehow Big Brother is watching everything that people do in their online lives. In Dana Boyd's article, "Why Youth (Heart) Social Network Sites", is says that, "everything that appears in public can be seen and heard by everybody and has the widest possible publicity". This is very true in relation to someone like your boss seeing what you thought was your "private" profile. Social Networking and the rise of New Media seem to facilitate privacy invasion no matter how much we try to keep our pages visible to only our "friends".